Collage: Paula Balondo; Source images: Courtesy of brandsSave this storySave this story
We all love full, fluttery lashes, but when falsies or thick, waterproof mascaras lead to scratchiness, itchiness, and tears, the best mascaras for sensitive eyes can give our lids much-needed relief. Here's why: The ocular area is one of the most delicate parts of our bodies, and many high-performance mascaras contain ingredients like waxes and dyes that aren’t necessarily harmful, but can sometimes lead to irritation, according to the board-certified dermatologists and ophthalmologists we spoke to. “Makeup particles can often be seen floating in the lacrimal ducts [also known as tear ducts],” says Donna Hart, MD, an Austin-based board-certified dermatologist. “Mascara can cause an irritant contact reaction from the breakdown of the product and the particles, causing a physical irritation to the eyes.”
Our Top Mascaras for Sensitive Eyes
- Best Overall: Clinique High Impact Mascara, $27
- Best Wand: Ilia Limitless Lash Mascara, $29
- Best Natural-Looking: Glossier Lash Slick, $20
- Best Shade Range: Tarte Tartelette Tubing Mascara, $28
So, are we skipping our favorite lash-lengthening formulas forever? Never. But in the spirit of moderation, we tapped the pros (as in, doctors) to find gentler, sensitive eye-friendly mascara formulas you can add to your lineup.
Frequently Asked QuestionsLargeChevron
- How can mascara irritate my eyes?
- How can I minimize mascara-related irritation?
- Meet the experts
- How we test and review products
- Our staff and testers
Best Overall: Clinique High Impact Mascara
Save to wishlist
Clinique
High Impact Mascara
Ulta Beauty
Allure managing editor Alessandra Foresto applying the Clinique High Impact Mascara
Alessandra Foresto
Why it's worth it: Ophthalmologist-tested? Check. Safe for contact lens wearers? Check. Allergy-tested? Check. Fragrance-free? Of course. Clinique’s High Impact Mascara is basically the gold standard for sensitive eyes. “A lot of my colleagues recommend this as a tried-and-true staple—and I’ve used this personally for a few years,” says Julie Chung, MD, a board-certified ophthalmologist based in Santa Monica, California. What makes it so reliable comes down to a few key conditioning ingredients: Panthenol and sodium hyaluronate keep lashes hydrated and flexible, while glycerin adds an extra layer of moisture to prevent brittleness and fallout.
Just as important is what’s left out. In addition to being fragrance-free, “this mascara does not contain parabens or phthalates, making it a good option for individuals who have sensitive eyes and are looking for a mascara that will not be irritating,” says Sonia Kelley, OD, MS, an optometrist based in Texas. And despite all that gentleness, it still delivers defined, fuller-looking lashes with just the right amount of drama.
Foresto before applying the Clinique High Impact Mascara
Alessandra Foresto
Foresto after applying the Clinique High Impact Mascara
Alessandra Foresto
Tester feedback from managing editor Alessandra Foresto
LargeChevron
“My eyes are easily irritated and often dry, so for years I didn’t even bother with mascara (the watery eyes, the itchiness and the black rims around my eyes from rubbing and smudging was just not worth it). I now have a few mascaras in my rotation that are gentle enough for my eyes and this Clinique one is now in the list! It’s super pigmented and adds volume and length but it does not flake at all. It doesn’t really add curl to my super straight lashes but that’s a tall ask I have yet to have a mascara tackle." —Alessandra Foresto, managing editor
More to know
LargeChevron
- Key ingredients: carnauba wax, panthenol
- Finish: volumizing, thickening
- Shades: 3
- Ophthalmologist-tested: yes
Best Wand: Ilia Limitless Lash Mascara
Save to wishlist
Ilia
Limitless Lash Mascara
Amazon
Nordstrom
Sephora
Allure senior commerce editor Sarah Felbin applying the Ilia Limitless Lash Mascara
Sarah Felbin
Why it's worth it: It's hard to find a single fault with Ilia's Readers' Choice Award-winning Limitless Lash Mascara. Take it from Dr. Hart, who shouts it out for being free of irritants like sulfates, parabens, and formaldehyde. “It does contain beeswax, which is a great ingredient for hydration, but can be an allergen for some,” she highlights. The nourishing mascara is also paired with a unique wand that can create different effects and finishes: One side of the brush is designed with shorter, more dense bristles to add volume, while the other, comb-like side lengthens and separates.
Felbin before applying the Ilia Limitless Lash Mascara
Sarah Felbin
Felbin after applying the Ilia Limitless Lash Mascara
Sarah Felbin
Tester feedback from senior commerce editor Sarah Felbin
LargeChevron
“The key to this mascara is the wand, in my opinion. The shorter-bristled side is excellent at applying an even coat of mascara from root to tip, and even does a great job of reaching my inner corners without smudging mascara all over my nose. But my favorite part is using the longer-bristled side to comb through each lash, removing clumps in seconds. My lashes look way longer and lusher with just a few swipes. As someone with oily eyelids, I'm also impressed by its staying power—no smudging or flaking.” —Sarah Felbin, senior commerce editor
More to know
LargeChevron
- Key ingredients: shea butter, keratin, beeswax
- Finish: lengthening, lifting
- Shades: 2
- Ophthalmologist-tested: yes
Best Natural-Looking: Glossier Lash Slick
Save to wishlist
Glossier
Lash Slick
Sephora
Allure former senior news editor Nicola Dall’Asen applying the Glossier Lash Slick
Nicola Dall'Asen
Why it's worth it: When you want people to compliment your lashes—not your mascara—reach for Glossier's Lash Slick. While the brand doesn’t explicitly market it as a tubing mascara, it acts like one: Lightweight polymers wrap each lash in flexible, tube-like layers that won’t flake, smear, or migrate into watery, sensitive eyes. “I often recommend this to people who experience irritation from traditional wax-heavy mascaras that can clump or flake,” says Dr. Collins. Each swipe also helps care for lashes, with panthenol to prevent shedding, peptides to reduce breakage, and glycerin for hydration. And when it’s time to take it off, “it comes away easily,” she adds. TLDR: It’s your lashes, just better.
Dall’Asen before applying the Glossier Lash Slick
Nicola Dall'Asen
Dall’Asen after applying the Glossier Lash Slick
Nicola Dall'Asen
Tester feedback from former senior news editor Nicola Dall’Asen
LargeChevron
"I feel totally naked without mascara, but I don't always want the full-throttle look of your standard black shade. Glossier's Lash Slick in Brown provides lengthening yet whisper-light coats in a warm brown tone, probably similar to your natural lashes if you're a brunette, for a 'Wait, are those real?' kind of look." —Nicola Dall’Asen, former senior news editor
More to know
LargeChevron
- Key ingredients: biotinoyl tripeptide-1, panthenol, glycerin
- Finish: lengthening
- Shades: 2
- Ophthalmologist-tested: yes
Best Shade Range: Tarte Tartelette Tubing Mascara
Save to wishlist
Tarte
Tartelette Tubing Mascara
Amazon
Ulta Beauty
Sephora
Allure senior staff writer Elizabeth Gulino applying the Tarte Tartelette Tubing Mascara
Elizabeth Gulino
Why it's worth it: Our editors are long-time fans of the original Tarte Tartelette Tubing Mascara, and Kristina Collins, MD, an Austin-based, double-board-certified dermatologist, says its lash-lengthening formula is one of the gentlest options for your delicate eyes, mainly for its ingredient list. “This tubing mascara is free of irritating ingredients like fragrance and parabens,” she says. That’s especially worth noting when you get into colored mascaras, which can sometimes be trickier for sensitive eyes since added pigments can increase the risk of irritation.
Tarte manages to offer a wearable shade range while still keeping the formula comfortable, thanks to a conditioning base of shea butter, castor oil, and carnauba wax. Never heard of tubing mascara? “It wraps each lash in a water-resistant tube for long-lasting wear without smudging or flaking, and it’s easy to remove with warm water,” adds Dr. Collins.
Gulino before applying the Tarte Tartelette Tubing Mascara
Elizabeth Gulino
Gulino after applying the Tarte Tartelette Tubing Mascara
Elizabeth Gulino
Tester feedback from senior staff writer Elizabeth Gulino
LargeChevron
“As someone who only wears tubing mascara, Tarte's version is the best one I've tried so far—and I've tried a lot! I particularly love how it lengthens my lashes, and I feel like I can put a few coats on without it getting clumpy or spider-y looking. It never smudges or flakes off on my eyes, which is a huge pet peeve of mine and one of the reasons I exclusively use tubing mascara. I'll use this forever!” —Elizabeth Gulino, senior staff writer
More to know
LargeChevron
- Key ingredients: shea butter, castor oil, carnauba wax
- Finish: volumizing, curling, lengthening
- Shades: 6
- Ophthalmologist-tested: not disclosed
Best Non-Clumping: Tower 28 MakeWaves Mascara
Save to wishlist
Tower 28
MakeWaves Mascara
Amazon
Sephora
Revolve
Allure shopping director Shanna Shipin applying the Tower 28 MakeWaves Mascara
Shanna Shipin
Why it's worth it: There are two really cool standout components you'll find in the Tower 28 MakeWaves Mascara, an Allure Best of Beauty Award winner. One is the formula, which contains Aquaflex Technology to define and hold the natural curl of your lashes for a more lifted effect that lasts all day long. Next is the triple-wave wand, as the brand calls it, meaning three suspended bands converge into one, making it easier for the bristles to grip and coat every single lash (even the baby corner hairs) without clumping. It’s the kind of lengthening mascara that sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers don’t have to think twice about, but still gives you that wow factor. “It’s gentle yet delivers dramatic volume and curl,” says Dr. Collins.
Shipin before applying the Tower 28 MakeWaves Mascara
Shanna Shipin
Shipin after applying the Tower 28 MakeWaves Mascara
Shanna Shipin
Tester feedback from senior commerce director Shanna Shipin
LargeChevron
“The hold on this mascara is incredible. I have short, dense, and straight lashes that are just so stubborn—but this coaxes some length and curl out of them! This is one of the few mascaras I can actually use without any kind of irritation. While it's not the most lengthening or curling formula you can get your hands on, it's so comfortable and doesn't flake or smudge. I love that it provides the perfect amount of natural-looking weight to my eyelashes so you can actually see them." —Shanna Shipin, senior commerce director
More to know
LargeChevron
- Key ingredients: Aquaflex Technology (polymers), castor oil
- Finish: volumizing, conditioning
- Shades: 2
- Ophthalmologist-tested: yes
More mascaras for sensitive eyes we love:
Best Smudge-Proof: Kevyn Aucoin The Volume Mascara
Save to wishlist
Kevyn Aucoin
The Volume Mascara
Dermstore
Bluemercury
Why it's worth it: We’ve already hyped tubing mascaras for sensitive eyes, but it’s worth saying again: Instead of traditional waxes that can melt, flake, or wander into your eyes, this formula uses polymers to wrap each lash in tiny, flexible “tubes.” Translation: no raccoon eyes—even if yours tend to water. The brush design is thoughtful, too. “Kevyn Aucoin’s The Volume Mascara has a great brush that’s small and precise, so there's no chance of applying too much, “says Dr. Chung. It gets right into the roots and those tricky lower lashes without overloading them—which is key, because excess product is usually what causes smudging in the first place. It also treats your lashes while it’s on: Jojoba oil and squalane add a lightweight conditioning layer, so lashes stay soft. When it’s time to remove it, it’s refreshingly low-effort: just warm water and a little pressure, and it slides right off.
More to know
LargeChevron
- Key ingredients: jojoba oil, squalane
- Finish: volumizing, lengthening, smudge-proof
- Shades: 1
- Ophthalmologist-tested: not disclosed
Best Lengthening: RMS Beauty Straight Up Volumizing Peptide Mascara
Save to wishlist
RMS Beauty
Straight Up Volumizing Peptide Mascara
Amazon
Ulta Beauty
Bluemercury
Why it's worth it: Peptides are usually the kind of ingredient you associate with skin care, but the brand’s founder, Rose Marie Swift, has always been known for weaving treatment-focused ingredients into her makeup. “RMS Beauty’s Straight Up Volumizing Peptide Mascara pairs conditioning peptides to support lash health while delivering noticeable length and definition,” says Dr. Collins.
It’s also packed with other skin-care extras that make a difference if your eyes are reactive: Shea butter and glycerin keep lashes hydrated, so they’re less prone to breakage and fallout, while soothing ingredients like purslane extract and antioxidant-rich white tea take down the chance of irritation around the eye area. “It’s a great choice for people who want a more dramatic effect in a clean formula,” says Dr. Collins.
More to know
LargeChevron
- Key ingredients: oligopeptide-2, shea butter, glycerin, purslane extract, white tea
- Finish: volumizing, lengthening, thickening, smudge-proof
- Shades: 1
- Ophthalmologist-tested: yes
Best Drugstore: Almay Multi-Benefit Mascara
Save to wishlist
Almay
Multi-Benefit Mascara
Amazon
Walmart
Why it's worth it: Almay Multi-Benefit Mascara has earned a long-standing reputation as one of the safest bets for sensitive eyes—and that really comes down to the brand’s entire DNA, which has always centered on hypoallergenic, irritation-minimizing formulas. “It’s ophthalmologist-tested and one of the oldest brands [editor’s note: established in 1931!] to prove efficacy for sensitive eyes,” says Dr. Chung. The formula is all about nourishing your lashes, too. Hydrolyzed keratin reinforces and smooths lashes, making them look fuller over time, while panthenol (pro-vitamin B5) provides flexibility. There’s also aloe for a bit of soothing support, plus amino acids to maintain lash strength. “I’ve rarely had a patient with sensitive eyes complain about this formula,” Dr. Chung adds.
More to know
LargeChevron
- Key ingredients: hydrolyzed keratin, panthenol (pro-vitamin B5), aloe, amino acids
- Finish: volumizing, lengthening, defining, conditioning
- Shades: 3 (plus a waterproof black shade)
- Ophthalmologist-tested: yes
Best Long-wearing: Lancôme Monsieur Big Mascara
Save to wishlist
Lancôme
Monsieur Big Mascara
Amazon
Nordstrom
Sephora
Why it's worth it: Waterproof mascaras aren’t usually the first recommendation for sensitive eyes as they rely on more tenacious film-formers and waxes to resist water, which often means harder removal (and more rubbing), plus a higher chance of dryness or irritation over time. Lancôme’s Monsieur Big Mascara is unique because it claims up to 24 hours of wear without needing a waterproof formula. Instead, it leans on a mix of flexible polymers and lightweight waxes to create that bold, fanned-out volume while staying soft and touchable—so you get serious staying power without the stiffness or flaking that can bother sensitive eyes.
There are also conditioning ingredients, such as hydrogenated jojoba oil, to prevent brittleness. And importantly, the formula is “without fragrance, nickel, paraben, and common preservatives, so it is a hypoallergenic and safe choice for sensitive eyes,” says Dr. Kelley.
More to know
LargeChevron
- Key ingredients: paraffin wax, carnauba wax
- Finish: volumizing
- Shades: 1
- Ophthalmologist-tested: yes
Frequently Asked Questions
How can mascara irritate my eyes?
You might pay attention to the ingredient list of the products you apply in larger amounts, but your eyes and the skin around them are especially susceptible to sensitivity from the ingredients that could be lingering in your current tube of mascara. "The skin on eyelids is the thinnest on the body, so anything applied to the eye area is easily absorbed," says Bruce Moskowitz, an assistant clinical professor of ophthalmology at Mount Sinai in New York City.
Due to the sensitive nature of the eye area, Dr. Kelley says mascaras in particular can be a main factor in chronic irritation, depending on their formulation. “First, you may develop sensitivity to an ingredient over time, even if it did not initially irritate your eyes,” she says. “Additionally, when you use your mascara brush, bacteria from your eyelashes can transfer onto it. The bacteria can accumulate on the brush and the container, increasing the risk of allergic reactions or infections.”
Dr. Kelley adds that when mascara is applied near the lash line, flakes and bacteria can irritate or infect the area, potentially blocking the oil-producing glands at the eyelid margin. “These glands are crucial for maintaining a healthy tear film, and when they become blocked, it can lead to dry and irritated eyes,” she says.
How can I minimize mascara-related irritation?
First, reconsider your mascara. To find a sensitivity-friendly mascara, our experts all agree: Check the ingredients label. “It's important to remember that everyone has different sensitivities and allergies, so always read the ingredient list, even for mascaras that are marketed as suitable for sensitive eyes, so you can avoid any ingredients you may be allergic to,” says Dr. Kelley. Ingredients like parabens, sodium benzoate, propylene glycol, fragrances, and certain dyes like black iron oxide can all contribute to eye and skin irritation or contact dermatitis. That’s why careful selection of ingredients and patch testing is crucial for individuals with sensitive eyes, says Dr. Kelley.
No matter which mascara you use, Dr. Kelley also notes that it’s essential to remove your mascara before going to bed in order to avoid irritation. “If you wear contact lenses, take them out first, and to prevent allergic reactions to the cleanser, use a hypoallergenic makeup remover to clean your lashes and the area around your eyes,” she says. And, of course, replace your mascara every three months to avoid bacterial buildup, according to Dr. Collins.
If you have an eye infection, Dr. Kelley says to avoid using mascara (and any other eye makeup in general) until it has cleared and discard the mascara you were using. “If your eyes are often irritated, don’t hesitate to reach out to your eye doctor so they can determine the underlying cause,” she adds.
Meet the experts
- Julie Chung, MD, a board-certified ophthalmologist based in Santa Monica, California
- Kristina Collins, MD, a double board-certified dermatologist based in Austin, Texas
- Donna Hart, MD, FAAD, a board-certified dermatologist at Westlake Dermatology based in Austin, Texas
- Sonia Kelley, OD, MS, an optometrist based in Texas
- Bruce Moskowitz, an assistant clinical professor of ophthalmology at Mount Sinaibased in New York City
How we test and review products
Before reviewing any makeup, we ask questions about a number of factors: What ingredients are in it? Does the brand offer a wide shade range inclusive of consumers with all skin tones and undertones? Is it safe for readers who have sensitive skin or wear contact lenses? Is it on the affordable side or more of a splurge? Is its packaging consciously designed or needlessly wasteful?
For our review of the best clean mascaras for sensitive eyes, we enlisted the help of multiple editors, writers, contributors, and makeup artists to review the products. This ensures our testing base spans different skin tones, genders, and dermatological conditions. We considered each product's performance across four primary categories: ingredients, wear and longevity, packaging, and inclusivity. For more on what's involved in our reporting, check out our complete reviews process and methodology page.
Our staff and testers
A beauty product is a personal purchase. You might be searching for a face cream to address persistent dryness or a new nail product to add to your Sunday self-care routine; you may simply be browsing around for the latest launches to hit the hair market. No matter what you seek or your individual needs and concerns, Allure wants to ensure that you love anything we recommend in our stories. We believe that having a diverse team of writers and editors—in addition to the wide range of outside testers and industry experts we regularly call upon—is essential to reaching that goal.
After all, can we really say a skin-care product is the "best" for people over 50 if the only testers we've solicited opinions from folks who have yet to hit 30? Can we honestly deem a high-end diffuser worthy of your hard-earned cash if it's never been tested on curls? We're proud that our staff spans a wide range of ages, skin tones, hair textures, genders, and backgrounds, which means that we are able to fairly assess any beauty product that comes into the beauty closet.
